6 Craigslist Alternative Sites in Canada for Sugar Daddy Seeking Baby

In the immediate aftermath of the demise of Craigslist personal ads in the USA, many sugar dating enthusiasts in Canada were forced to explore other avenues to find connections.

It didn’t take them long, though, to discover plenty of sites that are ideal Craigslist sugar daddy alternative sites for the Canadian market in 2026.

We’ll be taking a look at the best of these sugar daddy sites. First, though, if you’re a fan of sugar dating in major cities like Toronto or Vancouver, we thought you’d like to know why Craigslist is no longer an option for you.

Why you can’t use Craigslist for sugar dating

In 2018 Craigslist scrapped its personal ads section in the USA – popular with sugar daddy daters – after Congress passed the Fight Online Sex Trafficking (FOSTA) Act.

The Bill was aimed at making online platforms more accountable for user content that could contribute to child sex trafficking, but it was criticised by free speech advocates.

Whatever the pros and cons of the new law, it meant that online Craigslist sugar daddy dating devotees in Canada now had to find alternative sites to continue their lifestyle safely in 2026.

Top Craigslist sugar daddy alternative sites

We’ve been searching the internet for the best dating websites to find a sugar daddy, sugar mom, or sugar baby in Canada (whether female or male).

Here are our top picks.

#1 SecretBenefits.com

SecretBenefits.com emphasises the importance of honesty in building connections and aims to help nurture relationships based on compatibility through mutual lifestyle goals. In 2026, it stands out as a top choice for elite singles across Ontario and BC.

It has a dedicated Secret Benefits section for sugar daddies, sugar mommas and sugar babies, which it says is one of the safest sugar dating platforms available. For Canadian men, credit-based packages typically start around $82 CAD for 100 credits.

With an app version on Google Play, SecretBenefits incorporates a rigorous profile verification procedure that helps members to find their ideal sugar dating set-up fast – typically in just five days, according to the company.

SecretBenefits also boasts a range of special features, including a blog with tips on sugar dating within the Canadian regulatory landscape.

#2 SugarDaddy

Sugar Daddy positions itself as the world's best sugar daddy dating website. It’s certainly become one of the most popular and prolific sugar dating sites for Canadians in 2026.

Definitely for the serious sugar dater, SugarDaddy says its matches often blossom into loving, long-term relationships. A premium subscription for users in Canada is roughly $135 CAD per month.

The platform is mobile-optimised, so you don’t need to download an app to access the site, and full access is free for sugar babies from Montreal to Calgary.

The platform has a user-friendly interface, and signing up is fast and simple. You can verify your identity for safer dating, and SugarDaddy offers outstanding levels of customer service for its North American user base.

#3 OurSecret

Established in 2007 as a high-end sugar site, OurSecret is packed with more than 1.3 million successful, generous men looking for authentic, special relationships among a dating pool of over five million classy, attractive women looking for mentors. It has a massive presence in the Canadian professional community in 2026.

Silicon Valley-based OurSecret saves members’ time by narrowing down search results according to criteria such as ethnicity and location (including province-specific search), and you can get your photo verified for free to increase interest in your profile.

Smart mobile design makes it a breeze to maintain connections with potential matches on your smartphone while on the go. Standard membership for Canadian daddies is approximately $99 CAD per month.

#4 LuxuryDate

One of the biggest sugar dating sites in the world for sugar daddies and sugar babies, LuxuryDate has a simple sign-up process. Women in Canada join for free while men use a credit purchasing system (starting at about $69 CAD) that doesn’t tie you in to recurring monthly subscriptions.

There’s a strict photo verification system to keep out scammers and bots, and getting your account verified is fast and easy in 2026.

#5 MillionaireLove

Millionaire Love has valid reasons to justify its claim of being the pinnacle of luxury sugar dating for high-earning Canadians.

Based on the social networking model, the site helps society’s elite in cities like Ottawa and Edmonton get the most out of sugar dating and find honest, transparent relationships. The cost for a premium monthly plan is around $115 CAD.

With a strong emphasis on privacy and data security, MillionaireLove attracts men and women from across the globe with the highest standards of living, and moderators check all profiles.

The site is growing fast and has an impressive, minimalistic design, with a mobile app available in 2026.

#6 SugarDaddyForMe

With four million members and more than 1,000 new profiles daily, the SugarDaddyForMe platform remains a reliable choice for the Canadian market in 2026, even if it might initially seem a little old-fashioned.

Don’t let that put you off. The site is stylish and tasteful, user-friendly, and simple to navigate from a minimalistic main page. Registration is easy, and Canadian sugar daddies can search for matches with or without filters. Membership plans are often available for as low as $59 CAD per month.